EU Targets Pay-to-Win Games and Influencer Ads in New Digital Fairness Act

6 hours ago 3

The European Union has put forward a sweeping proposal that would ban pay-to-win and pay-to-progress features for minors, force influencers to label commercial content far more clearly, and fine companies up to 6 percent of their annual global turnover for the worst breaches. It is, if it becomes law, one of the most consequential interventions in how games are sold and how creators are paid on the internet. It is not law yet, and that distinction matters as much as anything in the proposal itself.

The European Commission published its proposal for a Digital Fairness Act on November 11, 2026, the centrepiece of a package aimed at updating consumer rules that were written before influencer marketing, in-app purchases and personalised feeds became everyday life. The Commission’s own fitness check in October 2024 had found gaps and legal uncertainty in the existing rules, and the new proposal is its answer: a directly applicable regulation that would replace the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, rather than another set of guidelines for member states to interpret differently.

What the Proposal Would Do to Games

For game makers, the sharpest provisions are the ones aimed at how games make money from their players, especially younger ones. Under Article 16 of the draft, pay-to-progress and pay-to-win mechanisms could no longer be offered to minors, where a game is directed at minors or the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that minors use it. That is a narrower ban than some headlines have suggested: it targets the offering of those mechanics to under-18s, not their existence for adult players. But in a market where free-to-play games live or die on their youngest and most engaged players, the commercial impact would still be enormous.

The proposal goes further. Article 15 addresses paid-for variable reward systems, the category that includes loot boxes, gacha mechanics and similar systems. Those could not be offered to minors either, and traders would have to tell consumers what types of items are available and the probability of obtaining them, as well as letting consumers disable paid-for variable reward systems if they wish. Article 14 would require items bought with paid-for virtual currencies to show their monetary value, or an estimated monetary value, and would require paid-for virtual currencies to be disabled by default for minors, activated only with a parent or guardian’s approval.

The law firm Mishcon de Reya, in its analysis of the proposal, notes that these restrictions go significantly beyond anything in current consumer regulation in either the EU or the UK, and will have significant consequences for the way games businesses monetise their products, especially in mobile games, where free-to-play is by far the dominant way of making money. That is not a neutral observation. Mobile games are built around exactly the mechanics the proposal targets: virtual currencies that obscure real prices, random rewards that encourage repeat spending, and progression systems that can be accelerated with a purchase.

How broad the ban would be in practice is genuinely unclear. As Dexerto notes, there are continual arguments about what can be classified as pay-to-win. Games such as Call of Duty and Fortnite maintain that their sold items do not grant a competitive advantage, while players have found ways to gain an edge with particular weapons and character skins. The proposal does not settle that argument. It leaves regulators, and eventually courts, to decide where cosmetic ends and competitive advantage begins, a line the industry has been arguing over for a decade.

What It Would Do to Influencer Marketing

The second front of the proposal is influencer advertising, and here the Commission’s intent is clearer. Influencers are already required to use hashtags such as ad, sponsored and gifted on commercial content. The Digital Fairness Act would strengthen that, requiring clear disclosure of influencer marketing, requiring influencers to be transparent about commercial content and preventing the exploitation of the trust of minors in their audience.

Article 11 would require influencer advertisements to make their commercial intent clear by carrying a clear and prominent disclosure using the terms “advertisement” or “commercial collaboration.” Brands and agencies using influencer services would have to secure compliance through contracts, or, where there is no contract, other appropriate means. The responsibility, in other words, would not sit with the creator alone. The brand paying for the post would be on the hook too, a shift that brings EU requirements broadly in line with the UK’s CAP Code, which already requires a prominent “Ad” label and makes clear that brands and influencers share responsibility.

For the creators and audiences who follow The Hype Magazine, this is the part of the proposal with the most immediate human stakes. Influencer marketing works because audiences trust the person recommending a product, and that trust is most easily exploited when the audience is young. A teenager watching a favourite streamer open loot boxes or praise a game is not reading the small print. The proposal’s answer is to make the commercial relationship impossible to miss, and to put the legal duty on both sides of the deal.

The Wider Crackdown: Dark Patterns, Addiction and Fake Scarcity

The games and influencer provisions sit inside a much broader package. Article 10 would prohibit online interfaces likely to deceive or manipulate consumers, and an annex to the draft lists ten dark patterns that would be unfair in all circumstances, including making false claims about the availability or popularity of a product, persistent scarcity messages during the ordering process, presenting refusal of an invitation to purchase as the wrong choice, and making changes to a choice disproportionately difficult.

Article 17 would require businesses whose digital products intentionally or foreseeably encourage compulsive or excessive use to provide tools to disable specified features, individually or all at once. The features named include autoplay and uninterrupted content consumption, notifications not triggered by the consumer’s own activity, features that encourage regular engagement including through penalties for failing to engage regularly, and prompts simulating interpersonal relations to encourage continued use. Anyone who has been nudged back into an app by a notification, a streak or a character pretending to miss them will recognise the catalogue.

The proposal also tackles subscription traps, requiring reminder notices and a prominent online termination option for contracts concluded online, with different timetables for longer and shorter contracts, and requiring express agreement before a free trial becomes a paid subscription. It would restrict personalised advertising and pricing based on sensitive personal data or the data of minors, require a human to be available on request when online customer service is ineffective, and introduce new rules for automated shopping systems that enter into contracts on a consumer’s behalf.

Enforcement would carry real weight. Companies resorting to unfair digital trade practices could face fines of as much as 6 percent of their annual global turnover in large-scale cases, according to Reuters’ reporting on the proposal. Alongside the Act itself, the Commission has proposed amendments to the Consumer Protection Cooperation Regulation that would give it direct enforcement powers to address cross-border breaches, and require non-EU traders to appoint a legal representative in the EU.

What Happens Now

None of this is law yet. The proposal must now be negotiated with EU member states and the European Parliament, a process that will take months and in which measures can be changed, softened or dropped. Trade associations for the industries most affected, such as Video Games Europe, will continue their efforts to moderate some of the proposed changes, as Mishcon de Reya notes, and businesses have already criticised overlaps with existing laws and with a separate proposed plan to keep children safe online.

That negotiation is where the proposal’s fate will be decided, and it is also where its ambiguities will matter most. A ban on pay-to-win mechanics for minors sounds straightforward until regulators have to define pay-to-win. A requirement for clear influencer disclosure sounds simple until it meets the reality of a creator’s feed, where a paid post, a gifted product and a genuine recommendation can look identical. The Commission has drafted a regulation that aims at the design of the internet itself, and the design of the internet is where the arguments will happen.

For players, parents and creators, the practical advice is simpler. Nothing changes today. The rules that exist now, including the hashtag disclosures and the existing consumer protections, remain the law while the proposal is debated. But the direction of travel is now on the record: the EU intends to treat the tricks that make people spend more than they planned, and the posts that hide who paid for them, as problems the law should solve, not just the market. The games industry and the creator economy have been warned, in the most formal way Brussels knows how.

The post EU Targets Pay-to-Win Games and Influencer Ads in New Digital Fairness Act appeared first on The Hype Magazine.

Read Entire Article