Robert Christgau And Carola Dibbell Talk New Documentary The Last Critic

3 days ago 4

A first-time filmmaker set out to portrait the Dean of American Rock Critics and came back with a love story — which is exactly the condition Christgau set when he agreed to be filmed: include the marriage.

The Last Critic, the debut feature from director Matty Wishnow, is a documentary about Robert Christgau, the music critic who has covered popular music since 1967, wrote more reviews than anyone else in the field and still publishes his monthly Consumer Guide column. It is also, by design, a portrait of his marriage to writer Carola Dibbell. The film won the jury prize at South by Southwest and the Oak Cliff Film Festival, as well as the 2026 Screen Dallas grand prize, and arrived in New York in mid-November for its premiere there, co-produced by longtime Rolling Stone contributor and editor Joe Levy.

Rolling Stone sat down with the couple in the East Village apartment they have called home for 50 years to talk about the documentary. Christgau said the film came out really well, and recalled that when Wishnow called to ask if he would do it, his first answer was yes — if the film included his marriage. Dibbell, his co-star by his own framing, put it plainly in the same conversation: it is still about him, and she is a co-star. When she first saw the film, she told the director it was a love story — a very strange love story. Christgau agreed, and called that the best thing about the movie.

A Marriage Of More Than 50 Years

The couple got together in the summer of 1972 — Dibbell had known Christgau when he was her friend Dominique’s boyfriend — and married in 1974. That partnership runs through everything Christgau has written since. In his 2015 memoir, Going Into the City: Portrait of a Critic as a Young Man, he wrote candidly about the relationship, and anyone who reads his work knows Dibbell’s presence in it: she is his interlocutor, his editor and, in Wishnow’s words, the person he is writing for alongside his readers. Wishnow has said her reaction significantly influences Christgau, and that she is at her most influential when she is into something he is fuzzy about.

The film leans on that daily reality. Its constant highlights, as Documentary magazine’s interview with Wishnow describes them, are scenes of the two going for walks, listening to music together and simply talking, in an apartment covered wall to wall with records, CDs, cassettes and books. Songwriter Randy Newman, a friend, appears in the film and recalls writing “Lost Without You” about the closeness of their marriage. The interview ranges further still — to the art of arguing, to playing basketball with Newman, and to the strange college semester when Christgau was Gene Simmons’ professor.

The Dean, At The Center For Once

Critics usually appear in music documentaries as a Greek chorus of talking heads in somebody else’s story. The Last Critic moves its subject to the unambiguous center. The interviewees include artists Christgau reviewed — Sonic Youth’s Thurston Moore and Newman among them — and writers he inspired, from the New Yorker’s Amanda Petrusich and the Bandsplain podcast’s Yasi Salek to Pulitzer-winning novelist Colson Whitehead, alongside critics including Greil Marcus, Kelefa Sanneh and Rob Sheffield. In the film, Christgau claims to have listened to some 250,000 hours of music; Wishnow, who spent long stretches in the apartment where music plays some 14 hours a day, has said he thinks that estimate undersells it.

The access came through Dibbell. Wishnow, an entrepreneur and podcaster who had never directed a documentary, built the project with co-producer and editor Paul Lovelace — who had interned for Christgau in college and made his NYU thesis film about him — and cinematographer and co-producer Ben. By Wishnow’s account, they were secretly asking Carola to help persuade Christgau at the same time they pitched him, because she is the way to get to him. Christgau’s own caveat, as the filmmakers have described it, was that the production not interrupt his work. He is, at 84, still working: the former Village Voice music editor publishes multiple pieces a month in his newsletter, And It Don’t Stop.

A Portrait, And A Warning

The film is also a melancholy one. It acknowledges Christgau’s age and the perilous state of the profession he spent his life pursuing, and it interviews younger critics about how precarious music criticism has become. Wishnow has said his reason for making it was not to celebrate criticism in the abstract but to take a portrait of what he called a master in sunset, and that he asked everyone in the movie the same question: why does criticism still matter?

Reviewing the film at SXSW, The Film Stage called it a fawning documentary in the best sense — one that acquits itself within rock-doc convention while offering real insight, and that works above all as a hangout movie and a portrait of a marriage. Variety’s Owen Gleiberman, himself a longtime critic, described it as captivating and as a testament to everything a great critic is. The film screened at the Montclair Film Festival in October, with Christgau, Dibbell, Lovelace and Levy appearing for a question-and-answer session.

That may be the film’s sharpest point. Christgau’s superpower, as the New York coverage of its premiere put it, is not only the snarky, densely intelligent prose but the depth of his care for the art he writes about. The Last Critic argues that the care and the marriage are the same story — which is what its subject insisted on, in his very first answer, before a camera ever rolled.

Source: Rolling Stone; Documentary magazine; The Film Stage; Cant Get Much Higher; NJArts.net; NYU Local via Medium

The post Robert Christgau And Carola Dibbell Talk New Documentary The Last Critic appeared first on The Hype Magazine.

Read Entire Article