Two marketers who were inside Nintendo at the time say the series was losing its audience — and the sales numbers back them up.
The Legend of Zelda is, today, one of the safest names in games: a series whose newest remake can sell five million copies in four days. According to two people who worked on the brand when things looked very different, that strength is easy to take for granted — because before The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild arrived in 2017, the series was, in their words, in dire straits. Kit Ellis and Krysta Yang, former Nintendo of America marketing leads who now host the Kit & Krysta Podcast, revisited that period on the latest episode of their show this week, and their account is blunt: the fan base was shrinking, new players were not coming in, and Nintendo knew it.
“They Were Selling Like Nothing”
The conversation started from a familiar piece of fan nostalgia. With Ocarina of Time back in the public eye on Switch 2, some players have been asking why Nintendo ever moved away from the traditional Zelda format at all — and, in Ellis’s telling, framing that move as something taken from fans at the height of the series’ popularity. Ellis called that version of events “revisionist history,” and Yang was more direct. “The series was in like dire straits,” she said. “They were selling like nothing.”
Ellis described the view from inside Nintendo of America’s marketing operation. “I remember I was going to the focus groups,” he said. “It was a really dark moment of like, the fan base is dwindling, this is not bringing in new players. We had so much data of like every game, it was fewer, the interest from the audience was getting smaller and smaller. They had to do something dramatic.” Yang summed up the mood in a line that has quickly become the quote attached to this story: “It was depressing. It was like, we are losing this.”
These are not outside commentators guessing at Nintendo’s internal mood. Ellis and Yang were the company’s public-facing marketing pair during the Wii U and early Switch era, hosting Nintendo’s own video programming, which makes their focus-group detail — the data, the shrinking interest, the sense of a series slipping away — a first-hand account of how the decline looked from inside the building.
The Sales Gap Behind The Story
The numbers support their version. Nintendo Everything, walking through the sales data alongside the podcast comments, notes that the traditional series appeared to peak with Twilight Princess, which sold nearly nine million copies. No brand-new traditional entry came close to that mark again. Skyward Sword, the first 3D Zelda built from the ground up for the Wii, sold under four million copies on its original release — 3.67 million, in the figure cited by Wccftech — on a console that sold more than 100 million units worldwide. TheGamer’s coverage of the podcast puts the same comparison at 3.5 million for Skyward Sword, against a series that had once treated nine million as normal. Critical reception was not the problem: Skyward Sword was a critical darling, and Twilight Princess was often criticized for being too derivative of Ocarina of Time. The formula was respected. It simply was not expanding the audience, and by Ellis’s account, it was not holding all of the audience it had.
Then Breath of the Wild rewrote the scale entirely. Released on March 3, 2017, as a launch title for the Nintendo Switch and the final Nintendo-published game for the Wii U, it was the product of a five-year rethink that began after Skyward Sword — a deliberate effort, led by director Hidemaro Fujibayashi and producer Eiji Aonuma, to break the series’ own conventions and rebuild Zelda as an open, explorable world. It has since sold almost 35 million copies: Nintendo’s own top-selling titles table puts the Switch version at 34.28 million units as of September 30, 2026, with roughly 1.7 million more on Wii U, making it by far the best-selling Zelda game ever. Its sequel, Tears of the Kingdom, sold almost 23 million copies. Put side by side, the contrast is the whole argument: the open-world reinvention did not just outsell the late traditional games — it sold roughly ten times what Skyward Sword had managed.
Why This Debate Is Happening Now
The timing of Kit and Krysta’s comments is not an accident. Nintendo recently announced that the Ocarina of Time remake on Switch 2 sold over five million copies in just four days — a pace that, as Nintendo Everything notes, could carry it past the original Nintendo 64 game’s lifetime total of 7.60 million, and within reach of Ocarina of Time 3D’s 6.44 million. That success has revived a genuine question in the fan base: if the classic format can still move numbers like that, why has there been no new traditional 3D Zelda since the shift?
Ellis and Yang’s answer is that the question has the history backwards. The traditional format was not shelved at its peak; it was replaced because, from where Nintendo sat, it was failing commercially, entry by entry, with focus-group data to prove it. The Ocarina boom of 2026 is happening inside a Zelda audience that Breath of the Wild rebuilt — an audience several times larger than the one the traditional games were reaching in their final years. Wccftech made a related point in its coverage: the 2021 Switch HD remaster of Skyward Sword outsold the original Wii release within a few months, riding the popularity Breath of the Wild created. In other words, the revival of interest in classic Zelda is real, but it is standing on ground the reinvention won back.
What It Means For Zelda’s Future
None of this settles where the series goes next, and both hosts’ comments leave that door open. Nintendo Life, reflecting on the same episode, notes that the warm reception for Ocarina of Time’s return shows an appetite for the classic structure alongside the open-world games, and raises the possibility of room for both formats in the future. What the podcast does settle is the record. The next time the Breath of the Wild gamble is described as Nintendo fixing something that was not broken, two of the people who watched the numbers come in have an answer ready: it was broken, they were watching it break, and the drastic move was the point.
The post Zelda Was in Dire Straits Before Breath of the Wild, Former Nintendo Marketing Leads Say appeared first on The Hype Magazine.

6 days ago
6
